For those of you who have read my Weekend ED Series from start to finish, you’ll know that I’ve never been admitted into an eating disorder treatment center.
The reasons vary on why. Before I even dared admit to myself that yes, I was suffering from anorexia nervosa, I was spending hours and hours in the library and my local Borders bookstore reading up on the subject. Unconsciously, I had already admitted to myself that something was wrong with me. And although I couldn’t pinpoint my issue exactly to anorexia (but anorexics are supposed to think she/he is fat! But anorexics don’t eat anything and I eat soooo much!), I was fascinated with what it is, its symptoms, and its treatment.
It’s true that an eating disorder is a self-engrossed disorder–– particularly because eating disordered individuals are completely lucid except when it comes to certain issues. We know what’s disordered and what’s not; we just can’t seem to do anything about it. Personally dealing with such a irrational obsession obsesses us with the irrationality of it all.
Anyway. One thing that fascinated me the most was eating disorder treatment centers. I guess deep down, I wanted to change. I wanted to be treated. And it seemed like every book pointed towards treatment centers as the ultimate solution: “Do you suspect your daughter/sister/friend is anorexic? Get her help! Send her to a treatment center!” And I guess it’s the same solution we come up with most addictions and psychiatric issues: Drug addict? Rehab! Alcholic? Rehab! Depression? Therapy! And shots of drugs!
So it was entirely depressing to read about the pitfalls of eating disorder treatment centers as well. Contrasting those self-help books were also autobiographies in which individuals shared how they went into treatment only to come out even more disordered than ever. After all, what are treatment centers but an enclosed gathering of equally disordered individuals?
The thought of spending three months with other anorexic girls didn’t appeal to me at all. In fact, it sounded downright toxic to me. I remember when I was sick, the first thing I noticed about another female was her weight. Was she skinnier than me? Was her waist narrower than mine? And then: What is she eating? More than me? Less? I didn’t think I could survive in that kind of hyper-sensitive, hyper-observant, hyper-competitive environment and not come out scarred.
Plus, just reading books about eating disorders inadvertently taught me even more disordered “tricks.” How much worse can it be when immersed in a society of intelligent people who are all struggling to even want to recover? Not to mention the rigid structure of the days during treatment. From the books I read, it seemed like each day followed a certain routine. Meals are fixed and based on meeting a certain requirement of calories. What the…that sounded exactly like how I was already living at the time! How would that help once I was released into the “real world?” How do I deal with the sudden spread of options, choices, and social situations?
The only thing that appealed to me about eating disorder treatment centers were the meal plans. And to be honest, that was my main purpose for reading those books. I wanted to be told what to eat. I wanted a strict plan I could follow, I loved that the treatment centers divided each meal into x amount of starch, y amount of vegetables or fruits, z amount of dairy or protein, which totaled into xyz amount of calories. I liked the rigidity of it, because it removed all freedom from me. I wouldn’t have to cry over having eaten too much or too little, because I’ll be given only the exact amount I needed. It sounded wonderful to me, not having to deal with choices. Not having to worry about unplanned situations and meals. I loved controlling things, yet I also desperately wanted to give it all up.
Thus when it actually came to the time when I wanted recovery…I talked with my parents and we decided not to go that route. Not that we had much of a choice, really, because I didn’t have health insurance, and treatment centers can cost over $1200 a day. A day! And you need to stay for at least three whole months for proper treatment. That’s about 90 days…about $108,000!! Who had that kind of money? Only big insurance companies, and not all insurance policies covered treatment centers anyway.
Oh, and I didn’t meet the requirements for treatment centers, either. During my first hospitalization, the doctors talked to numerous treatment centers all across the country, and all of them refused to admit me. Understandably, because with my medical condition at the time, I was a deathly liability to them. I might die in their facility, and the way I looked couldn’t possibly be healthy for the other patients. In addition, most treatment centers’ philosophy is that an eating disordered individual must meet a certain standard of nourishment and weight in order for recovery to take place. I would be the person I dreaded in a treatment center.
The doctors then had a final solution for me: let’s chuck you into the ICU, feed you calories intravenously and thus fatten you up a bit, and then send you to a treatment center. That’s when I totally flipped and checked myself out of the hospital.
About a few months after, I watched the documentary Thin with my mother. Thin, directed by Lauren Greenfield, was the first inside-look documentary revealing the day-to-days of The Renfrew Center, America’s most well-known eating disorder treatment center in Florida. I ordered the DVD as soon as it was released on Amazon. Even having denied treatment centers, I was still deeply intrigued by it. My dad refused to watch it because he said he was “already living in that reality” with me. So it was just my mother and I, with my mother sitting on the sofa, and I standing because sitting made me anxious.
I remember crying as I watched a particular scene in Thin. It was Polly’s (a patient) birthday, and the treatment center team celebrated it by basically forcing her to eat a cupcake. All the other patients had a cookie on their plate. They hugged and shouted words of encouragement and support to Polly while she stared with white knuckles at that fake-colored cupcake. After finishing that obligatory birthday present, she went to her room and cried.
As I watched her struggling to eat that cupcake, I was shaken with horror and empathy. At that moment, I felt like that was the worst birthday joke to play on a person struggling with anorexia. How is that supposed to help at all? Also, all the other patients had one freaking cookie! That’s like, 150 calories compared to the 250 calories of a cupcake! For the birthday girl! How completely, devastatingly unfair!! (It sounds a bit ridiculous writing this now, but that was honestly how I felt at the time).
By the end of that documentary, I felt heavy with the weight of despair. If treatment centers couldn’t completely treat us, then what? Isn’t that supposed to be the ultimate answer to our suffering? Are we doomed to a life of just maintaining our disordered behaviors? Just…surviving? If even paying hundreds of thousands of money, or fighting tooth-and-nail with an insurance company, and relegating months of personal freedom can’t help us…what can?
My mother, who was also tearing up beside me, turned to me and said, “Only Christ.” And I at the time struggled to believe that, because I wondered if Christ would deign to help someone as pathetic as me. And I wondered, what if this is God’s plan? What if He meant for me to live my entire life with a thorn in my side, as the Apostle Paul did? Maybe His purpose is to live with this disorder so I can be humbled and turn to others with empathy.
That night, I guzzled three bottles of vanilla-flavored Ensure. I don’t know, I guess I was suddenly desperate to be instantly better and be rid of this nightmare I was living. But the next day, the obsessions, the voices of anxiety and fear, the clings of self-disgust and hatred, started all over again.
I receive a lot of emails. Some of them have been from parents, desperate for help yet sucked dry of energy. Some of them have been from husbands, too, who pore through the Internet seeking help for his wasting wife. And most of them ask: What can I do? Can you recommend a treatment center to us?
And I have no answer. I’ve never been to a treatment center, and for a long time my perception of it has been leaning negative. But how do you tell a parent or a husband that? So I have no answer, only a twisting sympathy for these aching families.
I’ve been living without thinking about eating disorders for a long time now. Well, it feels long after having obsessed about it day-in-and-out for about five years. But the last few weeks, my obsession with it has been rekindled. The reason is because I’m researching treatment centers again…this time, as a journalist.
For the final project of my investigative journalism class, I’m focusing on investigating eating disorder treatment centers. As a reporter though, I’m re-looking at with an open mind. I’ve talked to individuals who tell me horror tales of their experience with treatment centers, but I’ve also had coffee with individuals who told me that their treatment center have changed their life for the better. I’ve even attended a conference about eating disorder treatment in San Diego, in which I’ve learned about some of the new skills and school of thoughts regarding treatment for eating disorders.
Things are gradually changing in the eating disorder field. Perceptions are shifting, and new research and technologies are approaching eating disorder treatment with gravity and hope. And I’m realizing that one eating disorder treatment is not the same as the other. And a treatment center five years ago is not the same as a treatment center now.
And here’s where I turn to you, my readers. In order to gain a more comprehensive understanding on this subject, I need a lot more interviews. If you’ve ever had experience with a treatment center in the United States, whether personally, or through a close family member, or as a health practitioner, please consider talking to me.
I mentioned that this is for a college class, but I’m planning to work on it longer term and hopefully, actually get it published. It might take a year. Or two years. I just want to do a thorough job.
I understand it’s a highly sensitive and personal subject. I am willing to work with you in terms of confidentiality and your comfort zone in revealing certain details. I have no intentions on turning this into some kind of sensationalizing piece. In the end, I want what every person involved in this field wants: to portray hope. Hope that recovery is possible.
Think about it. And when you’re ready, please contact me at burp.excuzme@gmail.com and include the word “interview” in your subject title. I also welcome any kind of suggestions, advice and questions.
And if possible, please spread the word for me. Tweet it, Facebook it, etc. Anything helps.
Related posts:







{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }
I truly believe that eating disorder treatment centers are a necessity when the eating disorder gets so severe that there is NO way that you can personally gain the weight back on your own. I have personally been in a few treatment centers and if you have ANY questions about how they vary, I would be happy to discuss.
Sophia!! It’s been ages. I’ve tried to keep up with your blog but I have tons of catching up to do! I am not sure if you received my email or perhaps I’d posted a comment a long time ago, on another of your blog entries. I was in Vietnam teaching English for a few months and near everything like blogs, facebook etc were blocked.
I just emailed you a mini-novel, haha. Not sure how helpful you’ll find it but do let me know if you receive and I’ll love to hear from you!
I think this is just one of many reasons why ED’s have such a high mortality rate. Treatment is so expensive and it is so rare to have insurance cover anything from counseling to nutrition appointments. And it is such a hard disorder to beat, given the rapid rates of relapses and people who get better, only to go back to treatment, only to get better and relapse again…
I can’t help you, since Im not in the US nor have I ever been IP, but I just wanted to say something. I am both doing some journalist work and social sciences research (work + Uni, respectively) and I have been tempted so often to dive back into the subject myself as well. It’s tempting to either write about it from a journalist point of view, or to research it as a double-knowledgeable scientist. I guess in both cases, we are all drawn to subjects that are close to our hearts since both journalistic as well as scientific research means spending lots of time and energy on a subject, but thusfar I have actively made myself refrain from going back into the subject. I first want to broaden my horizon, open up to other things. I dont want to be one of those people who will forever and only be concerned with eating disorders (I am NOT AT ALL implying you are btw, at all!). But yeah, I totally get your ‘itch’ to figure this ‘thing’ out from ‘the other side’/viewpoint!
Also, 12.000 a day!? What the ..! And this: “So it was just my mother and I, with my mother sitting on the sofa, and I standing because sitting made me anxious.” That almost made me laugh and cry over the irony. And the familiarity. Stupid disease.
Keep us posted on your article/book/series. I’d love to hear
Hope you’re well Sophia! x
Great Post- Sadly treatment centre did not work in my case. I walked out even more disordered with new behaviors under my belt. Thanks Sophie and stay blessed
Hi Sophia!
I love your blog, btw I think you’re a really great writer. Over the past 10 years, I have been IP at Johns Hopkins University ED program 5x and also Renfrew in Philly. I wouldn’t mind answering any questions/sharing what worked/didnt work for me if it would be helpful.
Sophia,
Your honesty in this post is AMAZING and courageous.
BTW- I felt EXACTLY the same way during the Polly scene.
And of course, she was forced to leave and later committed suicide.
I am spreading the word, and want to read a book by you (any book).
I am so excited that you are coming to Chicago!! I thought I’d never get the change to have lunch with you since the likelihood of me coming to California is moot. Woop! Congrats on the internship!!
Hi sophia.
i just wanna ask for some advices about ED..
How do you tell someone about your ed? because i always think that i’m not sick / skinny enough to meet the criteria for a person with ED..but i know that i might have one..i just can’t stop exercising and dieting..i keep thinking about food all day long, and it’s so frustrating..
i know i have to stop this destructive behavior, but i have no clue where to start..i’m afraid ppl won’t believe me, since i have a normal size body.. i’m so scared once i try to recover into normal lifestyle, i will be fat again.. ( i used to be fat before).,
thanks
So glad I found this site. My story is long, so I’ll try to shorten it. My ED started about 7 years ago. Went to the doc for a normal check-up, felt great, could’ve lost 10 lbs. but it didn’t bother me. Blood work came back and I was a mess – high blood sugar/cholesterol, etc.
They wanted to put me on meds unless I “went radical” diet/exercise wise. Well, since I wasn’t even 50 at the time, no way was I going to do meds so I went radical. And I just kept on going. I knew I had an ED but I didn’t purge, wasn’t classically anorexic, but I became obsessed with “healthy eating”. Hence, my understanding of orthorexia.
I went to support groups and all they did was depress me. It was a bunch of women sitting around talking about how they had been neglected/abused/mistreated in some way during their childhood. It was an ongoing “poor me” fest, and I always left feeling worse than when I got there. I saw no healing in site. Also, many of the women had been in and out of treatment. I’ve also seen this in other platforms for people who struggle with ED’s – in and out of very, very expensive treatment, where they make you eat ice cream every day.
I guess this is where I state that I am a born again Christian, and because of my faith and knowing that Jesus Christ is the Great Physician, I knew that I could trust Him completely to walk me through the disorder to find my healing. I also knew that in order to be healed it was less about me looking inward and lamenting my childhood/difficult marriage, etc., it was more about my looking outward towards others (how can I better love others more than myself) and looking upward at God. And I knew that in Him alone, by His indwelling Spirit, that I would overcome. I could not in any way do it by myself. Nor did I have the financial resources for a “treatment center”. And yes, while they may work for some, they are making an incredible profit at the expense of those with ED’s.
So I relied and still rely on the Lord. He has been with me every step of the way, and though I am not totally out of the woods yet, the progress I have made has been truly remarkable. Yes, some days are better than others, but I am in a far, far better place than I was several years ago, and even a year ago when I was at my lowest weight.
I trust in Jesus because He is totally trustworthy. Even if I take a step or two backwards now and again, I never, ever despair (which is what I see a lot of in people with ED’s who are relying on their own strength or a system). I will always get back up again and keep going forward, because I know that in Christ, I will be fully victorious. I am not alone – ever. And this fight is not my own, nor can it possibly be won in my own strength. It requires someone far more powerful than me to walk beside me every step of the way, carrying me when I need to be carried, challenging me and pressing me forward when that is required, as well.
I can say all this because with each small victory, it becomes a new part of my existence and I will continue to gain ground. I KNOW this. And I know it for anyone else that this, too, is possible.
Bottom line – Jesus is the answer to and the answer for absolutely EVERYTHING. Period. I hope all of you who are reading this find out for yourselves.
Thank you for this blog. I look forward to reading more, and may God bless you all!